CREATURELY REFLECTIONS
DO ANIMALS LAUGH?
BY SARAH A. BOWEN

"POOR CAT," MY FATHER REMARKED as he stared out the window. “I’m sure those squirrels are laughing at him.”
In this memory, I’m nearly 6 years old, and the sleek black cat in question lay stretched out on the picnic table, soaking in the sun, with seemingly no care in the world—even though three Sciurus carolinensis were dive-bombing him with sizeable walnuts. In between attacks, the squirrels chittered away. Reflecting back on this moment, I now wonder: Were they congratulating each other? Plotting the next attack? Or were they laughing?
For a long time, scientists believed laughter was uniquely human. But research over the past few decades suggests something contradictory. So far, studies have reported that at least 65 species of animals—including apes, parrots, dolphins, mongooses, cows, seals, and weasels—produce laughter-like sounds during play.
Laughter isn’t always easy for us to recognize, though. In one well-known 2003 study published in the journal Physiology & Behavior, Jaak Panksepp, Ph.D., discovered that rats emit ultrasonic “giggle” chirps when tickled or playing. Rats laugh, but we can’t hear it without sophisticated equipment. What’s more, the rats under study even sought out humans who tickled them, suggesting they enjoyed the experience. While I’m never a fan of keeping animals in labs to study them, this report intrigues me because it suggests that a species usually stereotyped for dirtiness or urban villainy is actually playful, making it easier for me to relate to them. (That said, out of an abundance of caution, and with an eye to animal consent, I’ll refrain from trying to tickle the Rattus norvegicus living near me in the New York City subway system.)
For a long time, scientists believed laughter was uniquely human. But research over the past few decades suggests something contradictory.
Some research hedges, cautious to describe animal emotions in the same words we use for human emotions, therefore using adjacent terms: “laughter-like” or “play vocalizations.” While it’s unclear if this is an attempt to assert human uniqueness, these researchers predicate laughter itself directly on understanding humor, which is a cognitive activity harder to measure than vocalizations.
Let’s return to the squirrels and my childhood cat. To me, the scene does seem to warrant humor or at least the acknowledgement that squirrels may appreciate irony. They could also have been delighting in their wit at evading feline capture. There is very little direct empirical research to help me name what my father and I witnessed. Studies show that squirrels have complex vocal systems, with a suite of barks, chatters, squeals, and kuk vocalizations, but researchers link these to alarm signaling, territory defense, and social communication. That doesn’t mean squirrels never make playful sounds, it simply means scientists haven’t yet clearly identified a squirrel equivalent to human laughter. What scientists research is usually linked to complex funding negotiations and protocol challenges. In relation to the latter, recall Panksepp’s discovery that the rats’ laugh was based on an observation that was inaudible to humans, after all.
Regardless, I think my multispecies memory matters. The world’s sacred texts sometimes describe animals not merely surviving in creation but delighting in it. Psalm 104 describes Leviathan—the great sea creature—as someone God formed “to sport with” in the ocean. The Hebrew verb lesaḥeq means not only “to sport,” but also “to play” or “to laugh.” A passage in the Babylonian Talmud (Avodah Zarah 3b) even suggests that God and Leviathan share a moment of play each day. In that sense, I like to think the God of my understanding gave squirrels a magnificent sense of play and humor too. &

SARAH A. BOWEN is program director of the Animal Chaplaincy Training program at Compassion Consortium, the first interfaith, interspiritual, and interspecies community. Visit sarahabowen.com.