ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE FOR THE SPIRITUAL TRAVELER

PROTECTING YOURSELF FROM SPIRITUAL CHARLATANS

BY RABBI RAMI SHAPIRO

Q: I feel so betrayed. I have followed Deepak Chopra for years, and learning that he had a deep connection to the pedophile Jeffrey Epstein is devastating. How can we be protected from spiritual charlatans?

RABBI RAMI: Every organization is made up of people, and people are prone to deceiving and being deceived. No church, synagogue, mosque, temple, or spiritual community can protect you from spiritual and religious charlatans, con artists, and opportunists. You must learn to protect yourself by being clear about your answer to five questions: 1) What is spirituality? 2) What constitutes an authentic spiritual practice? 3) How can I judge a practice’s effectiveness? 4) What is the role of a spiritual teacher? and 5) What is the place of money in a spiritual setting? Here is my take on each:

  1. Spirituality is the realization that every being is a manifestation of the nondual Absolute Being called by many names—God, YHVH, Allah, Brahman, Tao, Mother, and so on.
  2. A spiritual practice—meditation, chanting, affirmations, prayer, walking, gardening, or any other—is authentic if it leads to this realization.
  3. You know a practice is effective if it enhances your ability to engage with other beings justly and with compassion.
  4. The role of a teacher is to instruct you in an authentic practice without making you dependent on or open to exploitation by the teacher.
  5. To borrow from the ancient rabbis: “Do not make a spade of the Torah” (Pirke Avot 4:5). In other words, don’t use spiritual knowledge as a tool for personal gain. While it is fair to compensate teachers for their time and expertise, teaching spirituality is not a career, and authentic teachers step aside once the practice is sufficiently mastered.

The quest for God and the pursuit of wealth are often linked in the minds of clergy, gurus, and their followers. This is especially true in the United States, where spirituality and religion are big business and spiritual teachers and New Age influencers can earn millions of dollars, inviting charlatans whose psychopathy and narcissism masquerade as charisma and sainthood to prey on spiritual seekers. To protect yourself, remember that practice matters, not the teacher, and that once the realization of the Absolute is attained, even practice is unnecessary. As Van Morrison, one of my favorite singer-songwriters, sang: “No Guru, No Method, No Teacher.”

Q: I’m a devout Christian. My daughter is engaged to a Jew. I explained to her that Judaism and Christianity are incompatible and that they cannot raise their children in both religions as they claim. She says both religions are rooted in the commandment to “love your neighbor as yourself,” and that is how they will raise their children. Am I wrong? Isn’t it my job to help them raise their children in the Truth?

RR: Reducing Judaism and Christianity to “love your neighbor as yourself” does a disservice to both religions. “Love your neighbor” appears only once in the Torah (Leviticus 19:18) and four times in the gospels (Matthew 5:43, 22:39; Mark 12:31; and Luke 10:27). From a Jewish perspective, the greater commandment is to “welcome the stranger,” which appears 36 times in the Torah but only once in the gospels (Matthew 25:35). Two other noteworthy differences between Judaism and Christianity are Judaism’s assertion that every person has a direct connection with God, while Christianity insists that no one comes to God except through Christ (John 14:6), and Judaism’s elevation of deeds over faith—do justly, act kindly, and walk humbly with God (Micah 6:8)—while Christianity values faith over deeds—“by grace you have been saved through faith” (Ephesians 2:8).

Chances are, however, that your daughter and future son-in-law don’t know or care about any of this. They share a set of values that transcend religion and serve as the foundation of their relationship. They will use these values when raising their children. Unless they ask you for help, your job is to stay out of their way as they do so.

Q: My Gen X parents struggle to connect with their Gen Z daughter (me) on a spiritual level. My boomer grandparents believe you can help. Do you have any advice?

RR: I don’t. The only Gen struggle that matters to me is between Gen 1 and Gen 2. Gen 1 people believe they are created to “fill the earth and subdue it and have dominion over … every living thing …” (Genesis 1:28 NRSV). Gen 2 people believe they are created to serve and protect the earth (Genesis 2:15).

Gen 1 promotes zero-sum religions rooted in strict-father gods who separate people from nature and divide them into mutually exclusive camps, such as saved and damned, chosen and not chosen, true believers and infidels, high caste and low. Gen 2 promotes nonzero spiritualities that affirm all reality as divine. Where Gen 1 seeks to enslave, Gen 2 seeks to empower. Where Gen 1 desires the dominance of one race, sex, gender, religion, or ethnicity over others, Gen 2 desires a fearless world without war (Micah 4:3-4) where people are free from the conditioning of nationality, ethnicity, tribe, parental bias, sex, gender, race, class, religion, and every other narrative that keeps us from being a blessing to all the families of the earth, human and otherwise (Genesis 12:3).

Boomers, Gen X, Gen Y, or Gen Z can be part of Gen 1 or Gen 2, but I care only about Gen 2. Without Gen 2’s wisdom and insight, I fear humanity is doomed.

Q: My teacher insists that all teaching is propaganda and that I must overcome all teachings to become my true self and achieve unity with God. She offers various seminars to help me and others achieve this. Is she right?

RR: Let’s assume she is. This would mean her teaching, too, is propaganda that must be overcome. Now that we can ignore your teacher, let’s look at the idea of becoming your true self and achieving unity with God. You cannot become or achieve either because you already are both. Striving to be what you already are is exhausting and doomed from the start. So don’t start. Rather than striving to become your true self, ask who is aware of your false self. The answer is your true self. Then ask who is aware of this true self. The answer is an even truer self. Keep asking, and you will realize that all of this—the false self and the true self—is simply the play of the Only Self: God. Knowing this, you can observe any teaching while remaining free from all of them. No seminars required. &

RABBI RAMI SHAPIRO is an award-winning author of more than 36 books on religion and spirituality. For more than 50 years, he’s been devoted to a single teaching: Alles iz Gott, “Everything is God.” Visit rabbirami.com, and send questions to rabbirami@gmail.com.